The Night of December 23, 1987
Three Days After
Ruben Edera Ecleo Sr. died on December 20,
1987. Outside the Philippine Benevolent Missionaries Association that date
closes the story. Inside it, the story continues three days later, on the night
of December 23, with an event that members rarely speak of in public and have
passed among themselves for nearly four decades, in chapter meetings, in family
kitchens, in the quiet talk of the old, while almost no one outside the
movement has heard of it. The memory of that night, as the first eyewitnesses
tell it, is the root from which much of what followed has grown.
Ruben Ecleo Jr. was on the stage delivering
a speech. The mourning in the hall was heavy, and the members who gathered that
night had come to grieve a Master they believed they had lost. Then, according
to those present, the son's face began to change. The features became the
features of the father, and the voice, the cadence of speech, the gestures of
the hands followed. His sleeves, the witnesses say, seemed to shorten as his
height increased, and in what they describe as the blink of an eye the man speaking
from the stage was Ruben Sr.
The hall fell silent, the kind of silence
in which people hold their breath for fear of breaking what they are seeing.
Relief followed, and with it weeping, deep sighs, the elderly in tears at the
sight of the man they had buried in their hearts three days before. The
witnesses insist that what they experienced went beyond a felt presence or a
familiar voice speaking through another man's mouth, and that they saw Ruben
Sr. himself, face and body, standing on the stage and speaking to them.
A Master Known for Changing Form
The members were stunned that night, but
they were not wholly unprepared, because the Divine Master had been known for
transfigurations throughout his life. At conferences and gatherings where he
delivered the messages of General Adriano Dela Concepcion, members young and
old reported seeing his appearance change before them, and the number of people
who claim to have seen such things over the years runs, by the movement's own
reckoning, into the thousands.
For the members, these repeated occurrences
established something about the man before his death. In the language of the
esoteric traditions, which many of them did not know but which I came to know
before I ever met the movement, Ruben Sr. was understood to have mastery over
what those traditions call the subtle bodies, the capacity to project
consciousness and to alter the appearance of form. The night of December 23 was
remembered, then, as a familiar phenomenon in an unfamiliar vessel, since the
transformation the members had seen in the Master was now seen in his son, and
the Master himself was three days dead.
Tulku and Āveśa
The nearest language for what the witnesses
describe comes from Tibet, by way of the Theosophical movement that H. P.
Blavatsky co-founded in New York in 1875. The Tibetan word tulku, written sprul sku,
joins sprul pa, a verb meaning to
emanate, to appear, or to transform oneself, with sku, the honorific word for body. The compound means something like
an appearance in a body, or a body that has been transformed. In Tibetan
Buddhism the term names an emanation body, the form in which an awakened being
appears among the living, and it came to name the recognized reincarnate
teachers of the Tibetan lineages. Its Buddhist Sanskrit counterpart is nirmāṇakāya.
The Theosophists gave the word a second
sense. In their usage a tulku is also the condition in which a living Initiate
sends a portion of his consciousness into another person, usually a disciple or
messenger, for a longer or shorter time, so that the messenger transmits the
powers of the Initiate. Theosophical writers paired this sense with the
Sanskrit āveśa, from the prefix ā, "into," and the root viś, "to enter" or "to
possess," which yields an entering into, a temporary occupation of one
person by the consciousness of another. Later Theosophical writers say that
Blavatsky herself served many times during her public career as the temporary
tulku of one Initiate or another, which, if true, places the phenomenon in the
nineteenth century and in the West, far from the monasteries of Tibet.
Tibetan practice has a further term that
bears on the December night, though it bears on it at an angle. Phowa, written 'pho ba, is the transference of consciousness, a practice taught
chiefly for the moment of death, when the practitioner sends the mind out of
the dying body toward liberation. The entering of consciousness into another
body has its own name in the Tibetan sources, grong 'jug, and the literature that preserves it treats it as a
rare and dangerous art. I mention the distinction because the witnesses'
account combines both: a consciousness that has left its own body at death, and
that same consciousness entering another body three days later.
What the members report goes further than
either doctrine as the Theosophists stated it. The tulku of Blavatsky's circle
speaks with the mind of the Initiate while keeping the face of the messenger,
whereas the members say the face itself changed, and the height, and the
sleeves, until nothing of the son remained visible. If the doctrine describes a
consciousness lodged in a borrowed house, the witnesses describe the house
rebuilt in the owner's likeness, and in that respect the night of December 23
stands at the outer edge of the tradition, or beyond it.
The Son as Vessel
In the Theosophical account the Initiate
works through a prepared messenger, and the members point out that the son was
prepared. In one of his messages the Divine Master said that he had trained GM,
as the members call Ruben Jr., for thirteen years. Thirteen is a number the
movement already treats with care, since it was also the count of the Divine
Master's first disciples, and the members draw the connection without
prompting. Ruben Jr. stood, then, in the double position of natural heir and
trained disciple, and for those present on December 23 the transformation on
the stage settled any question of succession more decisively than an election
or a document could have.
That reading carries a weight the witnesses
may not have intended. A succession confirmed by a visible sign makes the
heir's authority depend on the sign, and the later history of the PBMA, with
its divisions and its quarrels over who speaks for the Founder, shows how much
rests on the memory of that night and how easily a memory can be claimed by one
party against another. I raise this here only as an observation about how the
story has been used, since the witnesses I draw on told it as an event and never
as an argument, and their testimony deserves to be heard on those terms before
anyone puts it to work.
Wherever You Go, There Is Ruben
Throughout his life the Divine Master told
his followers, "Wherever you go, there is Ruben. My Spirit is with you all
the time." Before December 23, 1987, the members heard those words as a
promise of spiritual nearness, the kind any beloved teacher might make to
students who must go on without him. After that night many of them heard the
same words as a description of something they had seen, a presence that had
passed through death and taken a visible form in the body of the son. The
sentence did not change, and the members' understanding of it changed
completely, in the same way that a farewell letter reads differently once the
writer has died.
Readers who know the Gospels will hear an
echo here, and I let it stand without pressing it. Mark sets the
transfiguration of Jesus on a mountain while he was still alive, his clothes
turning a white no fuller on earth could bleach (Mark 9:2–3), and the Easter
appearances afterward, where the risen Jesus is present but often hard to
recognize. The witnesses of December 23 describe something those two scenes
keep apart, a transfiguration after death in which the Master became
recognizable again through another man's body.
What the event was, the historian cannot
decide from the testimony alone. The witnesses were mourners in a crowded hall
at night, three days after a death they could hardly accept, and a skeptical
reader will weigh those conditions; the members will answer that they had seen
the Divine Master change form many times before and knew what they were looking
at. Both considerations belong in the record. What the testimony does
establish, beyond dispute, is that a large number of people who knew Ruben Sr.
well came away from that night convinced that they had seen him alive, and that
the conviction has been carried, quietly and with great care, through every
chapter of the movement for nearly forty years. For them the night of December
23 remains the night the promise was kept.

Comments
Post a Comment